Monday, 14 March 2016

Week 2

Week 2:

Background:
1_Tschumi
Architecture and Disjunction
Spaces and events
Published 1994 Massachusetts Institute of technology, USA
Audience: Architecture students, philosophers, architects

Purpose of publication:
To inform readers about spaces, time periods and events concerning architectural discourse and how there is no space without event. Raises an argument about social relevance and formal invention within architecture that is linked to events. Makes links between abstraction and narratives.

Context:
Theoretical approach is used, gives background information on events and time with mention around architectural critiques. Links to a debate about how architecture is seen in different time periods and how that time and events has influenced the spaces created. Touches on Space vs Program. Mentions a lot of theorists such as Barthes, Eco and Baudrilard, a book called “A Chronicle of Urban Politics”, Italo Calovino, Franz Kakka’s Burrow, Edgar Allan Poe’s Masque of the Red Death suggesting parallels between narrative and spatial sequences. James Joyce. Finnegans Wake.

Argument:
-       Theoretical approach start about architectural discourse, no space without event, historicism and formalism in every circle
-       Talks about architectural ideologies at the end of first paragraph, goes into 1970’s stylistic concerns of reduction and borrowed history.
-       Next stanza goes on to talk about a two faced coin architects becoming decorators and critics concentrating on surfaces
-       1980’s architecture is seen as a object of thought rather than a place with spaces and actions. Reinforces the word surface, political and ideological factors impacting architecture.
-       Goes on a big rave about the AA or Architectural Association displaying work in a different way to the other schools at that time, text, tapes, films, story boards, photographs etc. Focusses on photography as an example to explain complementary relations.
-       Touches on mixing of genres and disciplines and how they work together, 1974 series of literary projects all talking about contrast of ideas coming together and forming a framework.
-       Space versus program talking about a cycle of new programs starting to deconstruct a city and today it explores new codes of assemblage.
-       All link back to the start due as it relates to space and event, history and discourse of ideologies and frameworks.


Assessment:
Hard to read due to the fact of the reading being very wordy, uses words I didn’t know the meaning to and had to look up or remind myself what they mean. The points at first didn’t really pop out to me, definitely needs to be red thoroughly through a few times for the points to sink in and to catch what the author is trying to communicate. The argument seems fairly consistent and convincing, tied together with a lot of information packed sentences using sophisticated language. Logically works through the time periods also.


Summary:
Convincing as it talks about the time periods, events and ideologies in depth and logically. Not sure if I can find any faults I can comment on. Helps my understanding of the topic as it relates and explains some key ideas on time/space/event.

Other reading:
1A) Pallasmaa
The Eyes of the Skin
Oral versus Visual Space



Week 1

Week 1:

Background:
1) Juhani Pallasmaa
The Eyes of the Skin
Architecture and the Senses
The Task of Architecture.
Published 2005 in Great Britain
Audience: Architecture students, philosophers, architects

Purpose of publication:
To inform readers about space involving architecture, that it is timeless, constructs our world and how we live regardless of time weather it is the past, present or future.

Context:
Very theoretical approach with the language being used, also from the stance of the author has and the views shared with the reader. Such as the task of architecture being timeless, and structuring lives, becoming memories, based on sight now days rather than the other senses relating this to the human condition at the end. Quotes Frank Lloyd Wright in 1954 about the integrity needed in architecture.

Argument:
Pallasmaa argues the architectural world being undernourished due to only one of five senses being fulfilled which is sight. The aesthetic of how a created environment looks is taking priority, therefore neglecting how humans feel. Juhani Pallasmaa argues that architecture involves more than just sight but incorporates the human body, missing these crucial elements causes the body to feel misplaced. Architecture is more than just the ocular, it helps us remember, reflect, understand, eternalize and materialize linking back to the statement of architecture being timeless, a forever realm.

Assessment:
Not the easy to read and understand due to some of the language/words being used and the stringing together of large sentences, get lost a few times, had to look up words and also go back and read sentences twice or more. The argument seems fairly consistent and can see now how it links back to the first theoretical context/purpose.

Summary:
Fairly convincing, hard to judge to the shortness of the reading, does seem to drill in and over emphasis that architecture is based on more than just sight, giving a lot of different theories about space and time, very broad and open to start with. helps give me a feeling rather than an in-depth understanding of the topic as most of it went over my head.

Other reading:
1A) Pallasmaa
The Eyes of the Skin
Oral versus Visual Space

Notes:
-       Primordial = fundamental/basic/primeval/at the beginning of time
-       Edward T Hall
-       Walter J Ong
-       Shift from oral to written speech, Shift from sound to visual space
-       Situational thinking replaced by abstract thinking
-       Lucien Febvre
-       Hearing first and all the other senses first not seeing first             
-       Robert Mandrou
-       Seeing separates, the world and self, the other senses bring us closer to the world
-       Gaston Bachelard
-       Understanding comes from being in the world which comes from hearing, touching, smelling.