Background:
Simon Sadler
Notes Toward a History of Change
Places Journal, February 2016
Audience: Designers, Architecture students, philosophers, architects
Purpose of publication:
To make the viewers more aware of change in todays generation/era who seems to have given up on progress with post post modernism when compared with past generations and modernism. Sadler makes it easier for the younger generation to understand the strange concept of change by using current/just past examples with David Bowie, Steve Jobs and Kanye West.
Context:
Theoretical approach is used, examples of Bowie and Jobs are weak as they are used only as brief examples but the ideas and concepts on change are strong and backed up with good examples. Talks about how design practice has been a facilitator or a factor of change through modernism, post modernism and post postmodernism. Touches on Buddhism with quotes on change to get across the small and big change in the world.
Argument:
1. Introduces topic and change.
2. Sets up context with topic, change and context
3. Sets up the argument with topic, change, context. Introduces a worldview and
contemporary significance.
INTRO and CONTEXT
4. Frames discussion with a worldview, change and events. 5. Discusses perspective with worldview, change and events. 6. Gives examples on worldview, change and events.
7. Identifies key points on worldview, change and events.
BODY of ARGUMENT
8. Critiques change, the worldviews and events.
PIVOT POINT
9. Offers different perspectives on worldviews and change.
10. Concludes argument talking about change.
11. Challenges viewers to take action using context and contemporary significance
relating to Kanye West.
CONCLUSION
Author explores how change works in many ways and flutters around talking about big change, small change, change in times, macro politics and at the end doesn’t really conclude but talks about real change “sure, call it progress”.
Assessment:
Easy to read and follow due to the reliability with the examples used and the time it was published in (2016). Is on a topic that readers my age can relate to and understand,
Argument is consistent, convincing in a way that it leaves the reader thinking about change
but leaves it open to how you interpret change, weather the world today is really changing
or not. The referencing around the examples of David Bowie and Steve jobs is very loose but
gets the point across and allows more time focusing on the context and discussion rather
than the people.
Summary:
Convincing as it takes into consideration a range of views on change, uses examples loosely but to the benefit on unpacking the context and worldview more. Strong argument due to the strong and clear structure of the essay. The relativity to my generation helps a great deal in understanding this essay as well as the more simplified language.
Summary:
Convincing as it takes into consideration a range of views on change, uses examples loosely but to the benefit on unpacking the context and worldview more. Strong argument due to the strong and clear structure of the essay. The relativity to my generation helps a great deal in understanding this essay as well as the more simplified language.
No comments:
Post a Comment